This August, Hawaiians are scratching their heads, trying to figure out what Senator Daniel Inouye was thinking. In the last hours before the United States Senate’s summer vacation, Senator Inouye abandoned the Democratic majority in order to join the Republican Party in spporting George W. Bush’s plan to give extraordinary new spying powers to Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and the Director of National Intelligence, John Michael McConnell.
It’s a perplexing decision, given that Alberto Gonzales had been exposed as lying to Congress on multiple occasions, and abusing the power of his position as the nation’s top law enforcement official to promote the partisan political interests of the Republican Party. Why on earth would Daniel Inouye reward such outrageous behavior by giving Alberto Gonzales additional powers?
The Protect America Act gives Alberto Gonzales and John Michael McConnell the power to run electronic eavesdropping programs that create an immense dragnet scooping up the private emails, telephone calls, and web activity of American citizens. Essentially, there is no oversight of the spying – not from judges who would ordinarily give search warrants, or from Congress, which is supposed to have the power to conduct oversight of espionage – especially when it is directed against Americans. Only McConnell and Gonzales have the power to ensure that abuses do not occur. They’re given the power by the Protect America Act to be their own supervisors, with no one else able to say no to them.
In fact, the Protect America Act makes it a crime for anybody to deny an order from Alberto Gonzales or John Michael McConnell to join in an electronic spying operation. You can be thrown in prison for refusing their commands. You may not remember when you signed up for the Homeland Security Citizen Spy Brigade, but the Protect America Act doesn’t quibble about such things.
Why would Senator Inouye vote in favor of such a law? Part of the explanation may be that Inouye voted for the law without bothering to read it. After all, the Protect America Act was voted on just two days after being introduced into the Senate.
If that’s not the explanation, then I have no clue why Daniel Inouye would support such an obviously outrageous and unconstitutional law. If you’re one of Senator Inouye’s constituents in Hawaii, why don’t you call his office and ask his staff for an explanation:
808-541-2542